What constitutes a "refusal" for the DMV?

A failure or refusal to submit to a chemical test following a lawful arrest for DUI in California leads to a license suspension for between one and three years. The question then, is what constitutes a "refusal"?

A common problem is that some people have difficulty blowing into the breath machine after an arrest. A failure to complete a breath test may be as a result of insufficient breath or a faulty machine or some medical difficulty, but in these curcumstances, the suspect is under an obligation to submit to a blood test instead. A refusal to submit to a blood test following an aborted breath test will lead to a one to three year suspension.

Some people refuse to submit to a test and then change their mind. A request to submit to a test following an initial refusal, does not "cure" the refusal and the police are not obligated to allow a second bite at the cherry. Even if the police allow a test in these circumstances, the DMV may suspend based on the initial refusal.

Officer induced confusion is a well recognized "defense" to a refusal in DMV proceedings. This may occur if the arresting officer gives Miranda warnings following a DUI arrest, advising a suspect of their right to counsel, and then tells the suspect that they have no right to consult with an attorney before choosing a test. In these circumstances, the DMV should set aside the suspension.

Fear of needles is no excuse, although a suspect may request to see the qualifications of the person taking a blood sample as this is deemed a reasonable request.

Following an accident, a suspect who suffers a head injury and is thereby "confused" or medically impaired by the trauma, is not deemed responsible for a subsequent refusal and the suspension proceedings should be set aside.

A failure of the arresting officer to properly advise a suspect of their obligation to submit to a test and their choice of test, or a failure to advise on the consequences of a refusal may also lead to a set aside of the suspension.

The DMV do not have to establish that the licensee was impaired by alcohol or "over the limit" before suspending based on a refusal, although the arresting officer must detail some evidence of alcohol impairment before legally arresting someone for DUI. An unlawful arrest would lead to a set aside of the suspension.

It should also be noted that a dismissal of DUI charges in court, or a finding of not guilty by a jury, does not lead to a set aside of the DMV suspension based on a blood or breath test refusal.

If you have been arrested for a DUI in Los Angeles or Orange County and you are concerned about a lengthy license suspension based on a refusal to submit to a chemical test, it is essential that you consult with a DUI/DMV defense lawyer immediately to enable them to take the necessary steps to defend the DMV proceedings.

Our Proven Methods

Will Be Your Peace Of Mind

Don't wait to get the representation you need today. Fill out the form below to get started with a free case evaluation.

  • Please enter your name.
  • This isn't a valid phone number.
    Please enter your phone number.
  • This isn't a valid email address.
    Please enter your email address.
  • Please make a selection.
  • Please enter a message.
Get Started